ANALYSIS – AFC Toronto earned their first-ever Diana B. Matheson Cup in Ottawa at TD Place Stadium. AFC midfielder Olivia Chisholm had the game to remember of her life. The 17-year-old Toronto native was sharp all game long, and it was one of the big reasons why AFC Toronto came away as champions.
Note: All interviews with no link to quotes see below can be traced to this link here (Source: AFC Toronto YouTube Account on November 14, 2026).
AFC Toronto Earns Their Second Major Trophy in Club History
Olivia Chisholm Had A Game To Remember
Chisholm was one of the breakout performers of the 2026 NSL season. Before this season began, Chisholm was named the Canada Soccer’s 2025 Young Player of the Year.
Not known for scoring goals, Chisholm picked the right place and the right time to score her first-ever goal. This is what she said about it:
“I’ve been waiting all season to score my first goal, so it’s a pretty good time to score and to celebrate with all my teammates and coaching staff.”
Chisholm has been a regular for the club all year and a reliable midfielder. She can make defensive plays and has made a huge step-up this season.
One of the other players to step up this year was Lauren Rowe, who was credited with the game-winning assist.
READ MORE: Lauren Rowe: AFC Toronto’s 2026 Leading Goalscorer
Lauren Rowe Came Up Big for AFC Toronto in the NSL Playoffs
Rowe did not score a goal in the three games of the NSL playoffs. However, she dished out four assists in just three games to help her team win their first-ever Diana B. Matheson Cup.
Chisholm talked about the goal she scored, and Rowe’s crucial contribution to the goal, according to the Northern Super League YouTube Account:
“Well, I saw Lauren have the ball, she took a bit of a bigger touch, but I know with her speed that she was going to get there, and their whole backline kind of just dropped off. I knew the space was there for me.”
This has been a common theme for Rowe throughout the year. She used her speed to get into good positions to either score or set up a teammate. This was also clearly seen in the second leg against the Ottawa Rapid FC, where she made the final pass that led to Lena Silano and Nikayla Small scoring their goals.
Rowe might have been the most surprising player for the club this year. Across the NSL season and playoffs, the midfielder ranked second in goals for the club (just behind Kaylee Hunter) and fifth overall. She also led the team in assists, tied for second with the Ottawa Rapid FC’s Florence Belzile.
The Montreal Roses FC Had Chances to Score
The Montreal Roses FC did create some scoring chances in this game. Some were very close to becoming goals. Some examples include:
- Mimi Alidou intercepted the pass from Shelina Zadorsky. She saw Lisa Pechersky, who got a close-range shot, but it went just over the bar.
- Tanya Boychuk delivered the ball to Pechersky, but she couldn’t convert the scoring opportunity.
- Alidou had a close-range shot but sent it straight to AFC Toronto goalkeeper Sabrina D’Angelo.
These were just a few examples of chances Montreal had to score. Yes, D’Angelo made some saves, but it felt like Montreal left goals off the scoresheet in Saturday’s game. As a result, though, the Roses suffered their first defeat since August 7, when they lost 1-0 at the Stade Boréale to the Halifax Tides FC.
Other Factors: A Second-Straight Clean Sheet for AFC Toronto
AFC Toronto ended their 2026 NSL campaign with two straight clean sheets. While the Roses had their chances, the Mighty Maroons were solid defensively, and D’Angelo also had to be sharp. Some examples include:
- Colby Barnett cleared the ball in the 37th minute.
- Barnett cleared the ball in the 48th minute and took it from Pechersky within AFC’s box.
It was a very good read by Barnett in that moment in the 48th minute, as she read the ball perfectly and made sure Pechersky did not get to the ball.
AFC Toronto goalkeeper D’Angelo was also sharp, making saves when she needed to. This included the 67th minute, when she read the ball perfectly and got to it before Montreal forward Elysse Bennett could pounce on it deep in AFC Toronto’s box.
What This Means for AFC Toronto

This is the first time Toronto has won a major trophy through the playoffs in soccer since Toronto FC won the 2017 MLS Cup. It is also the first major women’s trophy Toronto has won in the playoffs since the now-defunct Toronto Six won the 2023 Isobel Cup in the now-former Premier Hockey Federation (PHF). The last time a Toronto sports team won a trophy was back in 2024, when the Toronto Argonauts won the Grey Cup.
Note: The Toronto Rock won their sixth NLL Championship earlier this year. However, some may not account for this as the Rock now plays at the TD Coliseum in Hamilton, Ontario, Canada.
Toronto also became the first-ever NSL team to win more than one major trophy. AFC Toronto have now won both the 2025 NSL Supporters’ Shield and the 2026 Diana B. Matheson Cup. When asked about this, this is what AFC Toronto head coach Marko Milanović said about it:
READ MORE: Vancouver Rise FC Wins The First-Ever Diana B. Matheson Cup
Many of these players worked hard to get to this point. After the NSL Final loss to the Vancouver Rise FC, these players had to regroup and accomplish their goal.
Photo Credit: Sophia Gutierrez for AFC Toronto, of Olivia Chisholm and Kaylee Hunter, on November 14, 2026.
